I'm not too well versed in atmospheric dispersion although I find maps of nuclide release to be intriguing. Nuclear accidents can cause a slew of nasty emitters to be scattered across the world. For this reason it is imperative for the global nuclear community to understand the negative side effects of nuclear-related incidents. This image given by NOAA is one misleading figure - this is what comes up when you search "radiation dispersion in the atmosphere" in Google:
http://media.independent.com/img/photos/2014/03/26/radioactive-water.jpg
Modeling the transport and fate of radionuclides in the environment is a critical problem for many applications. One paper written on geomorphology attempts to show a robust relationship with their inverse correlation used and point-based calibrations to predict diffusivity values across the landscape. Another describes their diffusion in concrete and soils and the problem of encasement failure for its effect on mobilization via water intrusion. Specifically, Technicium and Iodine were analyzed and it was found that there is great importance in ensuring little to now moisture in the sedimentary waste environment. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory and other national labs have done extensive leaching and diffusion testing for waste products.
Much of the quantitative analysis is based on Fick's law and diffusivity parameters. Each of the investigations above varied parameters like carbonation, concentration, material thicknesses, etc. and tried to determine the effects those variations had on the likelihood of release. The results from these analyses are presented with figures of merit and can impact the policies which regulatory oversight implements.
References:
http://www.pnnl.gov/main/publications/external/technical_reports/PNNL-20683.pdf

In class today we discovered that the figure is very misleading. It is not a map of radioactive release. Rather, it is a map of the size of the waves across the ocean. It is used as a scare tactic to frighten people (even more) about nuclear power.
ReplyDeleteThe graph you're using shows the maximum wave amplitude for the Tsunami. The map with all of its proper labels is linked at the end. More important than the fact that the graph is wrong, is that it's the first link that comes up when you google radiation dispersion. Misinformation is so incredibly rampant when it comes to the nuclear industry.
ReplyDeletehttp://nctr.pmel.noaa.gov/honshu20110311/honshu2011-globalmaxplot_ok.jpg
I'd have to agree with Nuclear Nancy. Misinformation is one of the biggest contributors to the fear of nuclear power. Sometimes the media uses misconstrued data and provides it to the public as a credible source, such as the figure above. When someone sees the image, they probably resort to judgmental thoughts without ever confirming the data to be credible OR in the right context.
ReplyDelete